Coto's Dads Take Matters Into Own Hands, Get A+: CHP Collision Report, 3Q2007
Kudos Coto Moms & Dads for doing what the CZ BOD refused to even consider!
October 5, 2007
The 3Q2007 CHP collision figures just received from the CHP show a quarterly collision level (on an annualized basis) comparable to the levels the Coto de Caza community experienced prior to expulsion of the CHP by the CZ Master Association board of directors, leaving the community with no pro-active traffic patrol for more than two years. After the firing of the CHP, the collision rate doubled each year, leading to the first traffic fatality in the community in December 2005, and three months later, the second fatality that was largely ignored, not only by the CZ board, but also by the Orange County Register.
The new low collision levels logged during 3Q2007 are despite the fact that total patrol hours per month are down roughly 60% from 2005 levels. That there is no concerted community awareness programs to speak of, and no proactive work done to identify and eliminate blind alleys, where most near miss accidents usually happen.
Annualized 2Q2007 CHP Collision Report for Coto de Caza. Source: CHP Capistrano, CA
Immediately after the first fatality in December 2005, the CZ master association board of directors was coerced into rehiring the CHP for pro-active traffic patrol. A note posted in the Coto Discussion Forum, authored by the then security chairperson, on Friday, December 9 in response to former board member, Joseph Morabito's charges of board negliglece reads:"The Board agreed last night to rehire the CHP after concerned residents voiced their opinion unequivocally and unanimously that we wanted CHP back in here immediately. CHP have started patrolling effective immediately in anticipation of a contract with CZ Master (a friend already received a tickets AND was glad they were back). I just wish it could have happened early. It just might have made a difference - and it breaks my heart".
It is often argued that hindsight is 20-20, however, what happens when public servants fail to even consider recommendations from responsible leaders, such as CHP's captain Helzig? The letter below was sent to the CZ master associatio board of directors days before the first fatality:
The CZ board of directors-friendly Orange County Register on the other hand, in the article titled Community mourns Coto teen killed in crash, published Friday, December 9, 2005 quotes then president Robert Varo’s misguided reason for firing the CHP "For three years, ending in January 2004, the CHP was contracted for traffic enforcement; the development association paid about $115,000 a year for up to 40 hours a week of patrols. CZ Master Association President Robert Varo said the agreement was ended because the community was not getting enough services for the money it paid"
While Hillsboro district delegate Robert Bellamy exhorts Coto parents to get involved in the most important public safety issue of proactive traffic patrol and writes “I believe that it is time for the residents of Coto de Caza to unite and very aggressively do what we as individuals can do to help secure proactive traffic enforcement from both the CHP and the OC Sheriff. Well placed telephone calls to CHP officials, Supervisor Wilson and Sheriff Carona will go a long way if we present a united front and maximize the political clout that residents here possess"
The move however, was largely ineffective in the short term, as the CZ master association let road certification expire, meaning that the CHP was not able to operate, then simply blamed it on a missing tickler file.
At about this time, we challenged the board to commit to lowering the old time high collision rate to 2002 levels. The board did not even respond.
Although CHP patrol hours are down during 2007, the citations per hour have doubled. Hardly an explanation for the significant decrease in the number of collisions during 3Q2007. We suspect that major drivers are the responsible Coto Moms and Dads, “cool dads”, notwithstanding as well as the criminalizing of underage drinking in California. Kudos Coto Moms & Dads! - you have done what the CZ BOD did not even consider doing!
We should note that according to CHP’ Officer Goodwin, two of the collisions were caused by two DUI 18 year old Coto residents, subsequently arrested.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter to the Varo/Mezger CZ Master Association board of directors days before the first traffic fatality in the community, dated 11/3, 2005
Greetings
I can certainly understand when the CZ BOD’s president says that it is mind boggling to deal with City Hall. It is more so when one deals with a BOD who wants to turn Coto into that same bureaucracy!
However, besides the fact that we are confident we can prove in a court of law that the decision to fire the CHP does not pass the Business Judgment Rule, simply bringing in the Sheriff is NOT pro-active traffic control.
As we have written so many times, we subscribe to CHP Captain Elzig’s pro-active traffic control formula:
Effective pro-active traffic controls must include:
1. Awareness campaign – In the past, Lt Deck and Captain Elzig have communicated with the CZ board and volunteered to launch such campaign. She has even volunteered to attend CZ Master Board meeting and discuss the issue with residents!
2. Visibility – simply having a CHP or Sheriff’s patrol car around the most dangerous roads minimizes speeding – even if the vehicles are un-manned - most accidents occur in three roads within Coto – hence these are not “accidents”.
3. Community patrol – as shareholders we have the duty to enforce the corporation’s rules. Neighborhood watches need to be coordinated with the other security initiatives.
4. Issuing citations – A strong deterrent – All violators should then be held accountable for their actions. This does not mean that only certain violators are cited. If socially challenged Country Club and Concert patrons, and others, do not have the self-control to hold their liquor or any other drugs, cannot or will not obey traffic laws, AND they are targeted, they should then be held accountable, just like and speeder or gate runner:
5. Monitoring – by monitoring relevant statistics (as compared to the useless data collected by Securitas), and communicating with the Nationhood watch, the community is best able to determine what adjustments are necessary.
So the issue is not whether to bring in the Sheriff or the CHP. The issue is to have an effective pro-active traffic control plan, which we have been requesting from this board for over two years.
The fact that the board is having predictable problems in bringing in the Sheriff, is not an excuse for not implementing the other components of the plan, ANY plan.
I urge the board, Keystone and legal counsel to take immediate action, articulating and implementing an effective pro-active traffic control plan. Otherwise, an objective person will immediately see individual and collective negligence written all over any future accidents within Coto.
Obviously, I have given this issue a lot of personal attention, volunteered to collaborate on a security strategic plan, and volunteered to provide data to the Keystone GM – no response.
This time, I do expect to hear from you on the subject at your earliest convenience, for the commonwealth of all Coto residents.
RELATED STORIES
Coto de Caza, 2Q2007 CHP Collision Summary
The newly elected CZ Master Association Board of directors? president has vowed to improve the relationship between the board and CHP management, a minimum requirement in order to increase the CHP traffic patrol to at least 2006 levels. We think that...
CotoBuzz December 2005 Newsletter
CZ BOD HOLDS THE COTO DE CAZA SECURITY AS HOSTAGE
For over two years, through use of WMP (Weapons of Mass Persuasion), and a perfected LID (Lie/litigate, ignore/ignoramus, or Deny/deflect/delay) Methodology, the CZ Board has held Coto security hostage....
CotoBuzz November 2005 Newsletter
THE BUCK NEVER STOPS AT THE CZ MASTER ASSOCIATION BOD! - In the Believe it Or Not category, since CotoBuzz started covering the CZ Master Association, the current board of directors has refused to publicly acknowledge that any of the decisions they have...
CotoBuzz October 2005 Newsletter
Halloween is Here: The Silencing of the Lamb: Michael Moore is acclaimed for his anti-administration fabrications in the 9/11 documentary. And Harold Pintner is awarded the literature Nobel Prize, as the academy calls the prolific political playwright,...
CotoBuzz Sep 2005 Newsletter
WELCOME TO THE CITY OF COTO! - – Soon the be officially known as RSM South, the place formerly known as Coto de Caza. In the September
The Enemy in Coto de Caza's Midst - The CHP!
Considering the history of Coto de Caza, Can you name all the service providers that have been on a quarterly review (rather than yearly review) ? to make sure the service it provides is acceptable? Can you name the members of the board of directors when...s
A Tribute to Mr. Morteza Manian On The First Anniversary of His Tragic Death
As Mr. Morteza Manian was riding his bicycle on a lazy Sunday afternoon, just like he had done so many times before, a 16 year old female driver of a Nissan Frontier approached the same intersection at Lexington Way and struck the left side of Mr. Manian.
Coto de Caza's Equus trailus patrolus publicus (horse trail patrols paid by the commonwealth)
We were befuddled by the recent announcement by the CZ Master Association board of directors of the impending deployment of mounted units of the Sheriff?s department to patrol the horse trails and fire roads that surround the community. After all, all...
Coto de Caza?s Public Safety, A Job For The Mounties - A Paraphrase of the Orange County Register ? But, why waste scarce, precious resources patrolling horse trails?XThe Mounties are Coming, the Mounties are Coming?.!X
It is no secret that the Orange County Register has been an ardent supporter of the Varo/Mezger administration. There is evidence that the editor collaborated with the board to silence critics, including the CotoBuzz Journal: The OCR board of directors...
CHP in Coto - Big Mouth CZ Bob- By Joseph Morabito, former member CZ Master Association Board of Directors
Hello All: I have heard that CHP officers are not volunteering to work in Coto even for the time and a half pay they would earn. So, we are not even getting the 40 hours a week that was the original deal under Glisson/Rose. It would seem that Bob...
The CotoBuzz Journal March 2007
Public Safety - A Job For the Gendarmerie Royale Du Coto de Caza! A Tribute to Mr. Morteza Manian On the First Anniversary of His Tragic Death
Coto De Caza, Ladera Ranch, Safest Communities in the Canyons ? Not!
According to the OCSD, Coto de Caza registered the highest incidence of crime/vandalism for 3Q2006. On the other hand, Ladera Ranch ended 2006 with a significant reduction in crime and vandalism.
CHP Patrol Hours Down, DUI-related Accidents Up: Coto de Caza Traffic Accident Trends - 1Q2007 - another Case of Cause-Effect
The California Highway Patrol (CHP) reports a total of 6 collision for the first quarter in 2007, one injury and 5 property damage only traffic collisions, for the un-incorporated area of Coto de Caza. Two of the collisions were DUI related.
Rancho Santa Margarita Residents arrested for DUI
The Capistrano Area Public Arrest Log for the week ending 1/28/2007 registered the arrest of two RMS residents.
Public Spectacles Work!
Public Spectacles worked For Ladera Ranch, and Laguna Woods Village, Why Not Coto de Caza? CHP enforcement hours in Coto de Caza have dropped some 60% from 2006 levels, mostly, because resources have been allocated by CHP management to other...
Coto de Caza?s Bastard Child: Public Safety
In just 15 short months, the community witnessed the absence of the CHP for proactive traffic patrol followed by two tragic traffic accidents. In the last one, the board blamed the victim, although the teen driver eventually pleaded guilty.
From Safety Committee to Committee to Turn Coto de Caza Into a City - Overview
This brief starts with the firing of a volunteer (early 2006) Public Safety Chairperson for her refusal to give up her free speech rights and promote Coto for city, before public safety.The president of the CZ Master Association board promises to fire...
The CotoBuzz Journal May 2007
CHP in Coto - Big Mouth CZ Bob- By Joseph Morabito, former member CZ Master Association Board of DirectorsHello All: I have heard that CHP officers are not volunteering to work in Coto even
The Varo anti-CHP Sentiment continues: CHP GO HOME, KEEP OUT OF OUR DUIs!
The Coto de Caza gates, including the automated ones are as reliable as the public utilities in the outskirts of Baghdad, yet the association continues paying for services barely-rendered, no questions asked.
CHP DOES ITS JOB – CZ BOARD PLEASE DO YOURS! - Despite the public abuse the CHP has received from the Coto de Caza board of directors ever since the board was coerced into bringing the CHP back for pro-active traffic patrol, figures indicate that the CHP is doing its job: Trend for accident rate is down and close to pre-firing levels. Just as important, the number of Coto residents arrested for DUI is down. See chart below for actual accident rate.
Law Enforcement – Evil, Necessary Evil, Or Noble Profession and Role Model? In open societies, we posit that law enforcement follows Winstren’s Law: Law Enforcement Goes Where it is Needed and Stays Where it is Wanted
1Q2007 Coto de Caza Crime and Vandalism Report
A comparison between the 1Q2006 and 1Q2007 Crime and Vandalism reports shows that a favorite Coto de Caza crime is fraud, that the Peter Pan Syndrome continues to be alive and well (crime is evenly distributed between kids and adults) and a criminal...
Select Blogzz & click icon
BlogSpot FeedBurner CotoBlogzz BraveNet Y!360
Archived Issues
General Information
HOA Resources
Emergency numbers
Public Safety Resources
Crime Watch
Sex Offenders in the Area
Real Time Traffic Report
LA Times Orange County
Subscribe
- What is RSS?
Area Links
ORANGE COUNTY BLOGS:
ADVERTISEMENT
To subscribe/unsubscribe to the CotoBuzz Journal or send Letters to the Editor : click here or send email to:
The CotoBuzz Journal P.O. Box 154 Trabuco Canyon, CA 92678 (509) 355-8895
Privacy Policy | Need Help? | Contact Us | Administrator: cotobuzz@yahoo.com
No comments:
Post a Comment