Wednesday, July 31, 2024

Camas City Council Chooses UnSafe Camas

The increase in traffic deaths  accross America, over the last ten years, coincides with the anti-law enforcement movement.

The New York Times Matthew Shaer rhetorically asks: "Why Are American Drivers So Deadly? After decades of declining fatality rates, dangerous driving has surged again... 
In 2021, 42,939 Americans died in car crashes, the highest toll in a decade and a half. Of those deaths, a sizable portion involved intoxicated or unrestrained drivers or vehicles traveling well in excess of local speed limits"






The increase in traffic deaths in the Pacific Northwest and accross America, over the last ten years, coincides with the anti-law enforcement movement.
 Elections have consequences If you live in Washington state, you voted for a Target 25, not Target Zero. And if in the City of Camas, WA you voted for an UnSafe Camas, instead of Camas Safe.

What will it be the next election cycle?


In 2019, California reported a motor vehicle fatality rate of 5.3 deaths per 100,000 people, slightly higher than the national average of 4.4. Injury collisions reported in California increased by an estimated 16% from 2018 to 2019 alone.

In Oregon, from 2013 to 2021, the number of traffic fatalities increased dramatically and has remained high.From 2013 to 2023 Oregon's number of traffic fatalities increased 88 percent and its fatality rate increased 70 percent.


Camas, WA

The City of Camas, unlike the City of Vancouver, it's next door neighbor has decided to follow Washington state's lead in the Inequity of the pursuit of equity over public safety. Instead of CamasSafe, it has chosen UnSafe Camas.

If it was not a serious matter, it would be comical: a simple parking jurisdictional question, turned into public safety issue and uncovering government waste:

My homeowners association decided to indiscriminately enforce public street 'no parking' regulations. A cursory look around the neighborhood showed a total disregard for public safety, including shoddy workmanship, bureaucratic red tape and widespread incompetence. While the dog catcher is often seen around the neighborhood, Camas PD is not.

I contacted Police Chief Tina Jones, who confirmed the HOA's no parking enforcement was a civil issue and because of lack of resources, no law enforcement patrol around the Woodburn Elementary School community was possible.

The next stop was the City's Code Enforcement. Officer Kraig Ainspach was gracious enough to confirm traffic sign obstruction and shoddy workmanship, which he said would be sent to the engineering department. Ainspach also incorrectly identified an overflow parking space as city-owned property.


Then it gets interesting: I tried to reach the City's Engineering Manager Steve Wall via email - he quickly blocked me. So, I figured I'd try the mayor's office: Steve Hogan & City Administrator Doug Quinn.


I then get a call from the greenest member of the city's engineering department who assures me there's nothing wrong with the roads or traffic signage around the Woodburn Elementary School community and cites a 'recent inspection around the community' but fails to describe what the inspection found, what was corrected and what remains to be done. He acknowledges the crash data around the area and that four of the last six are DUI-related but says "there's nothing we can do about it."

Another attempt at reaching City Hall produces a call back from Steve Wall - he was not aware of Washington state's Target Zero, Portland's Vision Zero or the concept of new product Introduction: in other words, he can't relate to the issues I have raised.

Vision Zero is a strategy to eliminate all traffic fatalities and severe injuries, while increasing safe, healthy, equitable mobility for all, whereas Washington state’s Target Zero patterned after Vision Zero, is a plan with the goal to reduce the number of traffic deaths and serious injuries on Washington’s roadways to zero by the year 2030 - a goal that will be sorely missed.




I next get a call back from an exasperated Doug Quinn who wants to know in seconds what the engineering manager has been unable to understand. Due to time constraints, we mutually agree to meet im person, July 18th. His office confirms the meeting for 9:00 am. Prior to the meeting, I email an proposed agenda, including recommendations;

Recomnendations

tTo:
To: Doug Quinn; Carrie Davis
Mon 7/29/2024 9:02 AM
Subject: Meeting Agenda Backgrounder 
 Greetings:  the suggestions I've sent fall into two categories:  Public safety and Government waste:  I sent the suggestions prior to the scheduled meeting, reproduced below for convenience:


In preparation for our scheduled meeting, I have written an essay 
 just published by CDN- on Washington's Public Safety Program called Target Zero. Target Zero is a plan with the goal to reduce the number of traffic deaths and serious injuries on Washington’s roadways to zero by the year 2030, to add transparency and to  hold officials accountable

It's not working.  Portland's Zero Vision is not working either.


As you may know, I had a nice phone conversation with Steve Wall.  I trust that he now better understands the issues I raised, as he was not familiar with  Target Zero nor the Concept of New Product Introduction in systems engineering.

Based on the essay, I have specific, requests/ suggestions, that I can elaborate on during our meeting:



PUBLIC SAFETY


[  ] DUI/Distracted driving accounts for four of the six traffic crashes in the Woodburn Elementary School community, consistent with state and nationwide statistics.  Need  aggressive awareness campaigns at the City and HOAs levels. Portland's PBOT makes yard signs available for pick up free, for example.

[  ] Need to reduce speeding in Woodburn and Tanoak.  Request two or three speed bumps.

[  ] Harmonize parking enforcement in public streets: Current process is wasteful, inefficient, inconsistent and incoherent and has potential for litigation.  I recommend the City takes over exclusive parking enforcement of  all city-owned streets: too many cooks spoil the broth.


[  ] Current overflow parking provides the opportunity for crime (old security professionals' MOM - Motive, Opportunity, Means - any crime is possible.) Overflow parking is often used as a personal  garage. Defeats the purpose of temporary parking spaces in the community.  Need to add tow away signage & have city enforcement


[  ] Sign Obstruction: While signage is not a factor in traffic crashes, it perpetuates the "don't care about safety" culture. The city can work with the various HOA's to keep up the maintenance

[  ] Visibility: the dog catcher is seen in the community regularly.  Not law enforcement.  The message: "the city cares more about unleashed dogs than speeding cars." Even a randomly staged patrol car can help.

[  ] The city should demonstrate public safety leadership by adopting a Vision Zero program, say a Camas Safe program, but unlike the state of Washington, really mean it.



[  ] EFFICIENCY/RED TAPE
The City offloads a lot of its work on HOAs. Every year, HOA laws change. The City- HOA interface hasn't changed. The City can demonstrate leadership by adopting a "New Product Introduction" Process:  The hand-off from the builder to the HOA, should be done like a New Product Introduction, including check-list & Q& A

Need an HOA Liason at the City to expedite problem resolution.

Regards
Doug shows up at 8:00 am. I show up at 9:00 as confirmed by his office. - the meeting never took place.

I followed up with Doug, July 29 to see if he has any questions: his response? "I have not seen anything new but have read your original email. Have you sent another note in regarding your concerns?"

Camas 24/7 a complete waste: issues are 'closed' when nothing is done: no explanation offered.

City of Camas Has No Comment


Haven't heard from the city since.

Not unexpected but predictable. We predicted as much three years ago:
2021 Camas City Council Voters Guide


Once informed, failure to act makes city officials liable for depraved indifference.


Conclusions?

Normalize Increase in traffic deaths like normalized high crime rate?

A Comedy?

A Comedy of errors?

Arrogant Incompetence?

The injustice of the pursuit of equity over public safety?

In an age of artificial intelligence, we are surrounded by bureaucratic
Arrogant Incompetence - AI

What is clear, is that the City of Camas has the opportunity to lead, and it squandered it.

No comments: