Blue Christmas Kith For Attorneys? - the Making of Docile Lawyers

Blue Christmas Kith For Attorneys? - the Making of Docile Lawyers

That lawyers are among the most miserable of men – an women – is well known



December 26, 2007


While the Ghost of Christmas past is still stored in our short-term memories, we are reminded that Blue Christmas is all too familiar to a number of people, but perhaps no more so than lawyers.


Harvard-trained, UCLA Law professor Sharon Dolovich, while a student at Harvard Law School wrote a piece titled "Making Docile Lawyers: An Essay on the Pacification of Law Students.", The piece is a "social psychology analysis of what happens to students at HLS to transform them from enthusiastic, engaged first year law students into fatalistic and pacified upper year students."


Maura A. Flood at Gonzaga Law School comments on Dolovich’s piece “I am certain that the effects she describes are felt by nearly every law student in nearly every law” and asks a rhetorical question: “Do law professors set out to create docile and demoralized lawyers? Of course not, but somehow it happens anyway…Could it have something to do with the fact that "justice" is a word that seldom makes its way into the first-year curriculum? I think it might. So many of the articles on first-year malaise, or law student angst, mention that students end up feeling set adrift from their values and beliefs, or made to feel that those values and beliefs are irrelevant”. A brief look at any university catalog clearly indicates that something similar happens in any field of study – that is, the first couple of years are replete with general education subjects that lead some students to ask something along the lines of “….why do I have to study art, my major is Engineering..!”, for instance.


“That lawyers are among the most miserable of men – an women – is well known”, writes WSJ columnist Sue Shellenbarger in the December 13, 2007 issue of the Wall Street Journal, citing widely quoted statistics from leading researcher on the subject, University of Ariozan’s Connie Beck: “Some 19% of lawyers suffer depression at any given time, compared with 6.7% of the population as a whole”, while Ronda Muir, Esq., a senior consultant with Robin Rolfe Resources and with law-practice experience in the US and Europe and an advanced study in psychology and conflict resolution has the following words of wisdom:

In general, lawyers score below the national average in emotional intelligence

Consider reverse psychology “You probably won’t….” might be a challenge the lawyer takes, Ms. Muir suggests

Lawyers are highly sensitive to criticism and likely to be defensive.

Do not play devil’s advocate, unless you can do so tactfully

Avoid emotional plays

Shellenbarger’s piece describes how “chronic anxiety over his work as an attorney snet Dan Lukasik skidding into a clinical depression”. Since then, and against friend’s and colleagues advice, Lukasik has come out of the closet by posting Lawyers With Depression, a website to help depressed lawyers. In his own words, “When I searched on-line for materials to read that would support me in my attempt to cope with depression and my law practice, what I found was sometimes helpful, but in the end, not sufficient” The site contains a number of bird of a feather articles and a number of tools to battle depression, including links to test for depression: Questionnaire, Treatment


Now that the closet is wide open, let us all have a prosperous 2008!



RELATED STORIES

The Scrutiny of Lawyers“There are plenty of jokes about lawyers, but everyone investigating them knows it can be a challenging task”, reads the preamble to an article by Ames Alexander, an investigative reporter with the Charlotte Observer for over 28 years and with more than 40 journalism awards to his credit.
Former Assistant Sheriff, Dove Canyon Resident Convicted Of Perjury & Misappropriation Of Public Funds
SANTA ANA -- Contrary to what certain Coto de Caza Board of Directors may think, there is semblance of law and order in Orange County.

A Passel of the F-Word in OC Politics, more popular than in Rap "Music"X
The F-word in Orange County politics seems to be more popular than ever before. More popular than the F-word used in Rap Music or the F-Word used in the recent mortgage meltdown.

Lawyer launches Web site, support group for lawyers with depression
The Buffalo Law Journal - "Lukasik has started the Web site www.lawyerswithdepression.com, and he also coordinated a support group for lawyers with depression that met for the first time June 1. Both resources are believed to be the first of their kind in New York state, and perhaps farther afield."

Even Lawyers Get the Blues
The Wall Street Journal profiles the changing landscape of attorneys and depression.

Lawyer Depresson Comes Out of the Closet
The American Bar Association discusses the changing attitudes of legal professionals towards depression.

One Attorney's Story
Attorney Dan Lukasik shares his personal struggle with Depression in this article from TRIAL Magazine.

The Scrutiny of Lawyers“There are plenty of jokes about lawyers, but everyone investigating them knows it can be a challenging task”, reads the preamble to an article by Ames Alexander, an investigative reporter with the Charlotte Observer for over 28 years and with more than 40 journalism awards to his credit.

Pssst, Can I Interest You In a Lawyer?- When there are too many policemen, there can be no liberty.
When there are too many soldiers, there can be no peace.
When there are too many lawyers, there can be no justice.

Sustainable Customer Relationship in US Legal System Paradox The July 31, 2007 issue of the Scotsman reports that a “radical overhaul of Scotland's legal system to give consumers greater choice and a cheaper service will be recommended today by the UK's competition watchdog” and that “the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) wants to lift restrictions on the way lawyers operate in Scotland, opening up the profession to competition for the first time”.

Of Trial Lawyers, the AAJ and the Democratic Party National College of Advocacy and AAJ Education maintain two distinct programs that recognize AAJ lawyer member efforts in pursuit of advanced legal learning and professional development—the Achievement Recognition Program and Advanced Studies in Trial Advocacy.

Annual Summer Youth Behind the Scenes Legal System Local Orange County high school students will have the opportunity next week to get a behind-the-scenes look at what it's like to be a prosecutor, defense attorney, police detective and judge during the 7th Annual Summer Youth Education Conference.

Former Haidl, Jaramillo Defense Attorney JG Cavallo Goes to Jail
According to the OCDA, defense attorney Joseph Gerard Cavallo, 52, Irvine, was sentenced today to six months in jail after pleading guilty on October 12, 2007 to three felony counts for conspiring to engage in attorney capping and an illegal attorney...

QTRAX MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES:

Effects of Stress-Inoculation Training for First Year Law Students

Former Haidl, Jaramillo Defense Attorney JG Cavallo Goes to Jail
According to the OCDA, defense attorney Joseph Gerard Cavallo, 52, Irvine, was sentenced today to six months in jail after pleading guilty on October 12, 2007 to three felony counts for conspiring to engage in attorney capping and an illegal attorney...

Unscrupulous Actions
The question is, what do these unscrupulous actions have to do with Orange County, or Coto de Caza for that matter? - Do they provide a lenitive effect?Irreconcilable conflict of interest. In Wade Vs. Soo Line Railroad, a routine worker?s compensation...

The Orange County DA's Office No Habla Christmas
A winter solstice holiday greeting specially for the OCDADecember 14, 2007 As part of an ongoing commitment to improve the quality of life in Orange County communities, the Orange County District Attorney's Office (OCDA), Delhi Community...
































Select Blogzz & click icon

BlogSpot FeedBurner CotoBlogzz BraveNet Y!360


Archived Issues

General Information

BlogzzSphere


Christian corruption Coto de Caza CZ BOD democracy DUI freeloaders Jesus judges lawyers Mezger OC Sheriff OCDA owners Radical Islam real estate satire South Orange County Vandalism Varo
Grab this swicki from eurekster.com



ADVERTISEMENT













To subscribe/unsubscribe to the CotoBuzz Journal or send Letters to the Editor : click here or send email to:



The CotoBuzz Journal P.O. Box 154 Trabuco Canyon, CA 92678 (509) 355-8895



Privacy Policy | Need Help? | Contact Us | Administrator: cotobuzz@yahoo.com